Current Controversies in Philosophy of Mind
Edited by Uriah Kriegel
Routledge – 2013 – 256 pages
Philosophy of mind is one of the most dynamic fields in philosophy, and one that invites debate around several key questions. There currently exist annotated tomes of primary sources, and a handful of single-authored introductions to the field, but there is no book that captures philosophy of mind’s recent dynamic exchanges for a student audience. By bringing compiling ten newly commissioned pieces in which leading philosophers square off on five central, related debates currently engaging the field, editor Uriah Kriegel has provided such a publication.The five debates include:
Preliminary descriptions of each chapter, annotated bibliographies for each controversy, and a supplemental guide to further controversies in philosophy of mind (with bibliographies) help provide clearer and richer views of active controversies for all readers.
This volume will be very useful to advanced students and professionals. The content is focused and current, and takes up issues underrepresented in other collections. The selections admirably combine accessibility with substance. It is particularly nice to have them organized in pairs that address debates in the recent literature from different perspectives. Overall Current Controversies in Philosophy of Mind gives the impression of efficiency: it should serve budding philosophers of mind well as an entry point into the contemporary literature.
Elijah Chudnoff, University of Miami
Prof. Kriegel's excellent book fills an important niche - it brings into focus current problems in philosophy of mind and actually puts into conversation with one another important voices in the debate. The supporting material with which he frames and contextualizes the works are themselves a valuable contribution to scholarship and perfect for students and beginning researchers alike.
Anthony Peressini, Marquette University
Introduction Uriah Kriegel, The Philosophy of Mind: Current and Perennial Controversies I. Mind and Body: The Prospects for Russellian Monism 1. Daniel Stoljar, "Four Types of Russellian Monism" 2. Derk Pereboom, "Russellian Monism and Absolutely Intrinsic Properties" Suggestions for Further Reading II. Mind in Body: The Scope and Nature of Embodied Cognition 3. Larry Shapiro, "When Is Cognition Embodied?" 4. Alvin Goldman, "The Bodily-Formats Approach to Embodied Cognition" Suggestions for Further Reading III. Consciousness: Representationalism and the Phenomenology of Moods 5. Amy Kind, "The Case Against Representationalism about Mood States" 6. Angela Mendelovici, "Pure Intentionalism about Moods and Emotions" Suggestions for Further Reading IV. Mental Representation: The Project of Naturalization 7.Uriah Kriegel, "Two Notions of Mental Representation" 8. Robert Rupert, "The Sufficiency of Objective Representationalism" Suggestions for Further Reading V. The Nature of Mind: The Importance of Consciousness 9. Charles Siewert, "Speaking up for Consciousness" 10. Geoffrey Lee, "Materialism and the Epistemic Significance of Consciousness" Suggestions for Further Reading Supplemental Guide to Further Controversies Index