Contradictions of Archaeological Theory
Engaging Critical Realism and Archaeological Theory
Published June 9th 2011 by Routledge – 184 pages
Series: Critical Realism: Interventions
Is current archaeological theory stuck at an impasse?
Sandra Wallace argues that archaeological theory has become mired as a result of logical and ontological contradictions. By showing that these contradictions are a result of common underlying philosophical assumptions and fallacies this book is able to show how a fresh approach to this discipline is necessary to resolve them, even if this requires re-examining some of the tenants of orthodox archaeology.
This fresh approach is achieved by using Critical Realism as an "under labourer" to philosophically evaluate archaeological theory. Starting by assessing the historical impact of philosophy on the discipline and then looking at the current relationship between archaeology and the ontology of the material this book facilitates the construction of discipline specific theory by archaeologists. The result is an approach to archaeology that allows both students and practitioners to free themselves from endemic contradictions and re-discover their approach to archaeological theory.
Preface Chapter 1: Introduction Chapter 2: Archaeological Theory Chapter 3: Philosophy and Archaeology Chapter 4: Critical Realism as Critique of Western Philosophy Chapter 5: Critical Realism as Philosophical Underlabourer Chapter 6: Diversity and Impasse in Current Archaeological Theorising Chapter 7: The Contradictions of Archaeological Theory Chapter 8: The Material in Archaeological Theory Chapter 9: Critical Realism, the Material and Absence Chapter 10: Time, Scale and the Ontology of the Material Chapter 11: Conclusions, Implications and Further Research Bibliography
Sandra Wallace is currently a research affiliate at the Department of Archaeology, University of Sydney, Australia, and the Principal Archaeologist for Artefact Heritage Services. Sandra’s research interests are archaeological theory, philosophies of materiality, critical realist theory and Australian Aboriginal archaeology.