Knowledge, Technology and Law
Edited by Emilie Cloatre, Martyn Pickersgill
Routledge – 2014 – 224 pages
Series: Law, Science and Society
Knowledge, Technology and Law examines the interface between studies of law, science and society, from the perspectives of socio-legal studies and science and technology studies (STS). The relationships between law, science and society are central to a diverse range of practical, ethical and theoretical issues. With an increasing emphasis on the fluidity and uncertainty of each of these areas, the analysis of their intersection(s) has become complex. Accordingly, scholars have borrowed from a range of disciplines and case studies to analyse not only how such intersections materialize, but also how and from where they should be approached. Notably, STS has provided a basis to explore the links between science and society, and socio-legal studies has offered many tools to understand the relationships between law and society. In recent years, a growing number of scholars have borrowed from both fields in order to further their efforts to understand the interconnectedness of law, science and society. This collection charts the important interface between studies of law, science and society, as explored from the perspectives of socio-legal studies and the increasingly influential field of STS. It brings together scholars from both areas to interrogate the joint roles of law and science in the construction and stabilization of socio-technical networks, objects, and standards, as well as their place in the production of contemporary social realities and subjectivities.
Introduction, Emilie Cloatre & Martyn Pickersgill, SECTION 1: GOVERNANCE, SCIENCE AND SOCIETY: Chapter 1: Epistemic Uncertainty in Contemporary Governance: Insights from Science and Technology Studies, Sujatha Raman; Chapter 2: From Alternative Medicine to Alternative Legality? Regulatory Orthodoxy and Creativity in Research Governance, Marie-Andrée Jacob; Chapter 3: Biomedical Research Governance: Challenges, Concepts and Solutions from the Socio-Legal Perspective, Shawn H.E. Harmon & Graeme Laurie; SECTION 2: LAW, SCIENCE AND SOCIAL NETWORKS: Chapter 4: Patient activism, networked resistance and the role of law, Anne-Maree Farrell; Chapter 5: The voice of the silence: How do UK patients challenge the assisted reproduction regulations by remaining silent?, Ilke Turkmendag; Chapter 6: Contingent Participation: Knowledge, Law and Science in Contexts of High Uncertainty, Mark L. Flear & Thomas Pfister, SECTION 3: SCIENTIFIC OBJECTS IN THE COURTROOM: Chapter 7: The Failure of the Polygraph? Lie Detection in the US Criminal Justice System, Andrew Balmer, Chapter 8: Unchaining research: towards an emancipatory approach to the study of legal processes in criminal law, Barbara Prainsack; Chapter 9: Colposcopy in the Courtroom: The medico-legal management of a controversial visualisation device, Gethin Rees; SECTION 4: REFLEXING SCIENCE, LAW AND SOCIETY: Chapter 10: Technology and legal artefacts: How to account for law, science, society and technology interactions in environmental regulation, Bettina Lange; Chapter 11: Text as technology, Alain Pottage; Chapter 12: Epistemic Federalism: Judicial Allocation of the Authority to Know, David Winickoff; Afterword, Robert Dingwall
Emilie Cloatre is based at Kent Law School; Martyn Pickersgill at the Centre for Population Health Sciences at the University of Edinburgh