Ethics and Academic Freedom in Educational Research
Edited by Pat Sikes, Heather Piper
Routledge – 2011 – 120 pages
Formal ethical review of research proposals is now almost the default requirement for all – staff and students – planning research under the auspices of colleges and universities in many parts of the world. With notable exceptions, the extant literature discussing educational research ethics takes a meta-ethical overview, is negatively critical about the ethics review process per se, or comes from America and focuses specifically on the workings of the Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) there.
This book, however, contains stories of lived experience from the UK, Spain, New Zealand, Bangladesh, and Australia dealing with, inter alia: dissatisfactions with criteria against which research proposals and designs and, by extension, researchers themselves, are judged to be ethical; problems encountered in obtaining ethical clearance; changes which have had to be made to plans which are believed to have affected the ensuing research process and outcomes; cases where ethical issues and difficulties arose and required considered responses despite permission to undertake the research in question being granted; and benefits perceived to accrue from ethical review procedures.
Ethics and Academic Freedom in Educational Research will be of interest to researchers, students, members of ethics review boards and those teaching research ethics, primarily at postgraduate but also at undergraduate level.
This book was originally published as a special issue of the International Journal of Research and Method in Education.
1. Ethical research, academic freedom and the role of ethics committees and review procedures in educational research Pat Sikes and Heather Piper 2. Socially just research for social justice: negotiating consent and safety in a participatory action research project Renée DePalma 3. One chairperson’s experience of ethical review: balancing principle, convention, relationship and risk in educational research John O’Neill 4. Research ethics and participatory research in an interdisciplinary technology-enhanced learning project Frances Tracy and Patrick Carmichael 5. Fieldwork for language education research in rural Bangladesh: ethical issues and dilemmas M. Obaidul Hamid 6. Researcher tales and research ethics: the spaces in which we find ourselves Julie White and Tanya Fitzgerald 7. Overstepping the mark: ethics procedures, risky research and education researchers Catherine Lomas Scott and Lariane Fonseca 8. How an exchange of perspectives led to tentative ethical guidelines for visual ethnography Clive C. Pope, Rosemary De Luca and Martin Tolich
Dr Pat Sikes is Professor of Qualitative Inquiry at the University of Sheffield, UK.
Dr Heather Piper is a Professorial Research Fellow within the Education and Social Research Institute (ESRI), at Manchester Metropolitan University, UK.