The Routledge Handbook of Civil-Military Relations
Edited by Thomas C. Bruneau, Florina Cristiana Matei
Routledge – 2013 – 380 pages
This new Handbook offers a wide-ranging, internationally focused overview of the field of civil–military relations.
The armed forces are central actors in most societies and are involved in many different roles. Amongst other activities, they engage in peace operations, support the police in fighting crime, support civilian authorities in dealing with natural disasters, and fight against terrorists and in internal conflicts. The existing literature on this subject is limited in its discussion of war-fighting and thus does not do justice to this variety of roles.
The Routledge Handbook of Civil–Military Relations not only fills this important lacuna, but offers an up-to-date comparative analysis which identifies three essential components in civil–military relations: (1) democratic civilian control; (2) operational effectiveness; and (3) the efficiency of the security institutions. Amalgamating ideas from key thinkers in the field, the book is organized into three main parts:
This new Handbook will be essential reading for students and practitioners in the fields of civil–military relations, defense studies, war and conflict studies, international security and IR in general.
"The framework proposed by the handbook and its validation through the series of case studies presents the necessary features to be later transformed into an updated theory of CMR and, hence, model of analysis. The Routledge Handbook of Civil-Military Relations is a valuable addition to the existing literature in the field of civil-military relations. In this respect, it will make an essential reading for students and practitioners in the fields of civil-military relations, defense studies, war and conflict studies, international security, and international relations in general." - Cezar Valescu, Aura Codreanu & Florin-Eduard Grosaru, Journal of Defense Resources Management, Vol. 3, 2 (5), October 2012
"Overall, this is a very useful book that deserves a wide readership. The book's cross-regional comparisons of cases from Africa, the Americas, Asia, and Europe are both valuable and unusual in this field of study and there is more than enough material here (including detailed references) to keep scholars and bring graduate students completely up to date. Moreover, the strong concern of the editors for practical issues in institutionalizing civilian control, military effectiveness, and military efficiency, makes this book also highly recommendable for practitioners in the fields of military, defense and security policies."- Aurel Croissant, E-IR journal
Introduction, Thomas C. Bruneau and Florina Cristiana Matei Part I: Development of the Field of Study 1. Impediments to the Accurate Conceptualization of Civil-Military Relations, Thomas C. Bruneau 2. Development of an Approach Through Debate, David Pion-Berlin and Thomas C, Bruneau 3. A New Conceptualization of Civil-Military Relations, Florina Cristiana Matei 4. Efficiency in the Use of Resources, Thomas C. Bruneau 5. Security Sector Reform, Timothy Edmunds 6. Escape from Huntington’s Labyrinth: Civil-Military Relations and Comparative Politics, José A. Olmeda Part II: Civil-Military Relations in Non-Democratic or Nominally Democratic Countries 7. Civil-Military Relations in a Dictatorship: North Korea, Jargalsaikhan Mendee 8. Learning from Failure: Egypt, Robert Springborg 9. Lessons not to Learn: Post-Communist Russia, Mikhail Tsypkin 10. The Transformation of the Bolivarian Armed Force: Venezuela, Harold A. Trinkunas 11. Rebuilding the Military Under Democratic Control: Iraq, Abbas Kadhim Part III: Civil-Military Relations in Democratic and Democratising States: Issues and Institutions A. Control: Four Case Studies 12. Asserting Civilian Control: Argentina, Thomas C. Bruneau and Florina Cristiana Matei 13. Civilian Influence in Defense: Slovenia, Florina Cristiana Matei 14. Shifting Lines of Governance in Insurgencies: India, Anshu N. Chatterjee 15. Executive Civilian Control of the Military: Spain, Florina Cristiana Matei and José A. Olmeda B. Effectiveness: Six Case Studies 16. Reforms in Professional Military Education: The United States, Thomas C. Bruneau 17. Discovering Peacekeeping as a New Mission: Mongolia, Thomas C. Bruneau and Jargalsaikhan Mendee 18. The Impact of NATO Membership on Military Effectiveness: Hungary, Florina Cristiana Matei 19. Redefining Defense Strategy: France, Hélène Dieck 20. Building an Integrated Military in Post-Conflict Societies: Lebanon, Anne Marie Baylouny 21. Civil-Military Relations in an Emerging Democracy: South Africa, Jessica Piombo C. Control and Effectiveness: Six Case Studies 22. Developing a Robust Ministry of Defense and a Joint Staff: Portugal, Thomas C. Bruneau 23. Democratic Civilian Control and Military Effectiveness: Chile, Florina Cristiana Matei and Marcos Robledo 24. Achieving Neutrality and Effectiveness: Austria, Donald Abenheim and Carolyn Halladay 25. Stability in Flux: Policy, Strategy, and Institutions in Germany, Donald Abenheim and Carolyn Halladay 26. NATO, the Demand for Democratic Control and Military Effectiveness: Romania, Florina Cristiana Matei 27. The Impact of the Partnership for Peace on Civil-Military Relations: Moldova, Diana Molodilo and Valeriu Mija 28. Conclusion: Lessons Learned and Best Practices, Thomas C. Bruneau and Florina Cristiana Matei
Thomas C. Bruneau is Distinguished Professor of National Security Affairs at the U.S. Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, California. He has published more than 15 books in English and Portuguese, and recent edited books include, with Lucia Dammert and Elizabeth Skinner, Maras: Gang Violence and Security in Central America (2011) and, with Harold Trinkunas, Global Politics of Defense Reform (2008).
Florina Cristiana (Cris) Matei is Lecturer at the Center for Civil–Military Relations (CCMR) at the Naval Postgraduate School.