Neutrality in Twentieth-Century Europe
Intersections of Science, Culture, and Politics after the First World War
Edited by Rebecka Lettevall, Geert Somsen, Sven Widmalm
Routledge – 2012 – 352 pages
Whether in science or in international politics, neutrality has sometimes been promoted, not only as a viable political alternative but as a lofty ideal – in politics by nations proclaiming their peacefulness, in science as an underpinning of epistemology, in journalism and other intellectual pursuits as a foundation of a professional ethos. Time and again scientists and other intellectuals have claimed their endeavors to be neutral, elevated above the world of partisan conflict and power politics. This volume studies the resonances between neutrality in science and culture and neutrality in politics. By analyzing the activities of scientists, intellectuals, and politicians (sometimes overlapping categories) of mostly neutral nations in the First World War and after, it traces how an ideology of neutralism was developed that soon was embraced by international organizations.
This book explores how the notion of neutrality has been used and how a neutralist discourse developed in history. None of the contributions take claims of neutrality at face value – some even show how they were made to advance partisan interests. The concept was typically clustered with notions, such as peace, internationalism, objectivity, rationality, and civilization. But its meaning was changeable – varying with professional, ideological, or national context. As such, Neutrality in Twentieth-Century Europe presents a different perspective on the century than the story of the great belligerent powers, and one in which science, culture, and politics are inextricably mixed.
"A stimulating, new look at how scientific values mix with political identities." – Geert Vanpaemel, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
1. Introduction Rebecka Lettevall, Geert Somsen, and Sven Widmalm Part I: Points of Departure: The breakdown of internationalism in science and culture and its effects 2. Probing the Master Narrative of Scientific Internationalism: Nationals and Neutrals in the 1920s Brigitte Schroeder Part II: International Collaborations: Neutrality in science 3. "Holland’s Calling": Dutch Scientists’ Self-fashioning as International Mediators Geert Somsen 4. "A superior type of universal civilisation": Science as Politics in Sweden, 1917-1926 Sven Widmalm 5. "Has the Swedish Academy of Sciences … seen nothing, heard nothing, and understood nothing?" The First World War, Biased Neutrality, and the Nobel Prizes in Science Robert Marc Friedman 6. Pursuing Common Cultural Ideals: Niels Bohr, Neutrality, and International Scientific Collaboration during the Inter-War Period Henrik Knudsen and Henry Nielsen 7. Caught-up by Politics? The Solvay Councils on Physics and the Trials of Neutrality Kenneth Bertrams 8. The Scientific Construction of Swiss Neutrality Daniel Speich Chassé Part III: Intellectual Positions: Neutrality and Culture 9. A Castle in the Centre: The First Czechoslovak Republic and European Cooperation (1918-1938) Carlos Reijnen 10. Prague Zionism, the Czechoslovak State, and the Rise of German National Socialism: the Figure of Max Brod (1914-1933) Gaëlle Vassogne 11. Legitimacy through Neutrality: Resources of Journalism in the International Press Visit to Sweden in 1923 Patrik Lundell 12. Of Twins and Time: Scientists, Intellectual Cooperation, and the League of Nations Jimena Canales Part IV: Political Visions: Neutrality and Peace 13. Eye-deep in Hell: Heinrich Lammasch, the Confederation of Neutral States, and Austrian Neutrality, 1899-1920 Georg Cavallar 14. Nobel Science of Peace: Norwegian Neutrality, Internationalism and the Nobel Peace Prize Vidar Enebakk 15. Neutrality and Humanitarianism: Fridtjof Nansen and the Nansen Passports Rebecka Lettevall List of Contributors Notes Index
Rebecka Lettevall is Associate Professor and Docent of the History of Ideas at Södertörn University, Sweden. She is author of The Idea of Kosmopolis: Ethics, Aesthetics, and Politics of World Citizenship (2008).
Geert Somsen is University Docent in the Department of History at the University of Maastricht, the Netherlands.
Sven Widmalm is Professor in the Department of Technology and Social Change at Linköping University, Sweden.