Skip to Content

Permissible Advantage?

The Moral Consequences of Elite Schooling

By Alan Peshkin

Routledge – 2000 – 152 pages

Series: Sociocultural, Political, and Historical Studies in Education

Purchasing Options:

  • Add to CartPaperback: $43.95
    978-0-8058-2467-4
    July 31st 2000
  • Add to CartHardback: $105.00
    978-0-8058-2466-7
    July 31st 2000

Description

This study of Edgewood Academy--a private, elite college preparatory high school--examines what moral choices look like when they are made by the participants in an exceptionally wealthy school, and what the very existence of a privileged school indicates about American society. It extends Peshkin's ongoing exploration of U.S. high schools and their communities, each focused in a different sociocultural setting. In this particular inquiry, he began with two central questions:

* What is a school like whose students enter with a determined disposition to attend college, and all of whom are selected on the promise they display for college success?

* What can be learned from studying Edgewood Academy that transcends the particular case of this school?

The volume opens with a description of how moral choices look when they are made by the participants in an exceedingly wealthy school. There is a general picture of the Academy, a discussion of the processes the school uses to insure the quality of its students and educators, and an overview of teachers and students that reveals what is commendable about each group. These chapters clarify what a school of ample financial means and wise leadership can do. Peshkin goes on to reflect briefly on privilege and concludes with a discussion of what the very existence of a privileged school indicates about American society. Schools, he suggests, are about much more than what goes on inside them--they mirror what is and is not at stake for their particular constituents--and function similarly for the nation.

Edgewood Academy's host community is not a village, town, church, or tribe, as in Peshkin's previous studies. It is a community created by shared aspirations for high-level academic attainment and its associated benefits. Affluence and towering academic achievement are the two most relevant factors. In this book, advantage occupies center stage. The school's excellence is documented not to extol its success, but, rather, to call attention to what is available for its students that is not available for most American children. The focus, ultimately, is on educational justice as illuminated by the advantage of Academy students--that is, on justice denied, not because anyone or any group or agency consciously, planfully sets out to do injustice to other children, but because injustice happens as the artifact of imagined limitations of resources and means. Peshkin's purpose is not to detail the particulars of how educational justice is denied to the many, but to portray and examine the meaning of a privileged school where educational justice prevails for the few.

Reviews

"Peshkin's analysis tells us much about the nature of the institution that enshrines excellence, with all its concomitant tensions. For the psychologist, reaching a clearer understanding of ambient excellence and its causes and then doing one's best to apply it elsewhere would be a profound sharing of wealth."

American Journal of Psychology

Contents

Contents: Preface. A Moral Outlook. Circumstances of Education. Judgments for Excellence. The Goodness of Teachers. The Goodness of Students. Privilege. American Values.

Name: Permissible Advantage?: The Moral Consequences of Elite Schooling (Paperback)Routledge 
Description: By Alan Peshkin. This study of Edgewood Academy--a private, elite college preparatory high school--examines what moral choices look like when they are made by the participants in an exceptionally wealthy school, and what the very existence of a privileged school...
Categories: Primary/Elementary Education, School Leadership, Management & Administration, Sociology of Education