Intuition in Judgment and Decision Making
Edited by Henning Plessner, Cornelia Betsch, Tilmann Betsch
Psychology Press – 2008
The central goal of this volume is to bring the learning perspective into the discussion of intuition in judgment and decision making. The book gathers recent work on intuitive decision making that goes beyond the current dominant heuristic processing perspective. However, that does not mean that the book will strictly oppose this perspective. The unique perspective of this book will help to tie together these different conceptualizations of intuition and develop an integrative approach to the psychological understanding of intuition in judgment and decision making. Accordingly, some of the chapters reflect prior research from the heuristic processing perspective in the new light of the learning perspective.
This book provides a representative overview of what we currently know about intuition in judgment and decision making. The authors provide latest theoretical developments, integrative frameworks and state-of-the-art reviews of research in the laboratory and in the field. Moreover, some chapters deal with applied topics. Intuition in Judgment and Decision Making aims not only at the interest of students and researchers of psychology, but also at scholars from neighboring social and behavioral sciences such as economy, sociology, political sciences, and neurosciences.
"Psychology and decision sciences have for too long been out of the mainstream of the other natural sciences, mainly evolutionary biology and neuroscience, by putting the conscious cart before the unconscious horse. Finally, a collection of essays by leading experts in human reasoning and decision making that takes the unconscious seriously as a force in producing important decisions. This book provides a much needed counterweight to the dominant 'conscious and rational' model of human decision making. Hats off to the editors for gathering just those authors who are doing the cutting edge research in this area, as well as for the original idea to produce this much needed collection." - John A. Bargh, Yale University
"This volume examines in depth "intuition", one of the most often mentioned and yet least systematically investigated concepts of lay psychology. It provides a well rounded discussion that covers the manifold aspects of this fascinating phenomenon. The book is successful in bringing together ample cutting edge insights into what intuitive judgment might entail. It is timely, thought provoking and comprehensive. A must read for anyone interested in the intricacies of human judgment and impression formation." - Arie W. Kruglanski, University of Maryland
"Intuition in Judgment and Decision Making is the most insightful scholarly book about intuition ever written. For years to come, future scholarship on intuition will draw on its ideas and fascinating revelations." - David G. Myers, Hope College, author of Intuition: Its Powers and Perils
"The study of human cognition is replete with dichotomies: controlled vs. automatic, implicit vs. explicit, analytic vs. heuristic, associative vs. rule based, experiential vs. rational, procedural vs. declarative or just plain and simple System 1 vs. System 2. The common theme is that we have access to two distinct modes of processing-one that is "intuitive" and the other "deliberate". This invaluable book provides an extensive exploration of how these modes might be used in judgment and decision making, with a particular emphasis on the perhaps underestimated role of intuition. Leading researchers present new data on how these two modes might work alone and in concert to improve our judgments and decisions. The impressive breadth and depth of coverage will allow readers to draw informed conclusions about the power of intuitive thought." - Ben Newell, University of New South Wales, Sydney
"Overall, Intuition provides an excellent overview of many different fields of research within this intriguing area…" - Stuart W. G. Derbyshire, PsycCRITIQUES
"The role of intuition in human performance has been often overlooked, or even treated with disdain. The contributions to this volume catalogue a wide variety of scientific research aimed at uncovering the mechanisms underlying the acquisition of intuitive knowledge…such a volume is possible suggests that perhaps intuition is finally beginning to get the respect it deserves." - Robert C. Mathews, Applied Cognitive Psychology
Contents: H. Plessner, C. Betsch, T. Betsch, Preface. Part I: The Nature of Intuition. T. Betsch, The Nature of Intuition and Its Neglect in Research on Judgment and Decision Making. S. Epstein, Intuition From the Perspective of Cognitive-Experiential Self-Theory. R. Deutsch, F. Strack, Variants of Judgment and Decision-Making: The Perspective of the Reflective-Impulsive Model. R.M. Hamm, Cue by Hypothesis Interactions in Descriptive Modeling of Unconscious Use of Multiple Intuitve Judgment Strategies. K.G. Volz, D. Yves von Cramron, Can Neuroscience Tell a Story About Intuition? Part II: Learning and Intuition. R.M. Hogarth, On the Learning of Intuition. H. Plessner, T. Betsch, E. Schallies, C. Schwieren, Automatic Online-Formation of Implicit Attitudes Towards Politicians as a Basis for Intuitive Voting Behavior. M. Raab, J.G. Johnson, Implicit Learning as a Means to Intuitive Decision Making in Sports. I. Erev, D. Shimonowitch, A. Schurr, R. Hertwig, Base Rates: How to Make the Intuitive Mind Appreciate or Neglect Them. K. Fiedler, Y. Kareev, Implications and Ramifications of a Sample-Size Approach to Intuition. Part III: Emotion and Intuition. M. Zeelenberg, R. Nelissen, R. Pieters, Emotion, Motivation, and Decision Making: A Feeling-Is-for-Doing Approach. E.U. Weber, P. Lindemann, From Intuition to Analysis: Making Decisions With Your Head, Your Heart, or by the Book. J. Haidt, S. Kesebir, In the Forest of Value: Why Moral Intuitions Are Different From Other Kinds. C. Betsch, Chronic Preferences for Intuition and Deliberation in Decision Making: Lessons Learned About Intuition From an Individual Differences Approach. Part IV: The Assets and Deficits of Intuition. H. Plessner, S. Czenna, The Benefits of Intuition. S. Haberstroh, Intuitive and Deliberate Strategies in Frequency Estimation. C. Unkelbach, H. Plessner, The Sampling Trap of Intuitive Judgments: Can Reflection Reach Beyond Sampling Constraints? S. Catty, J. Halberstadt, The Use and Disruption of Familiarity in Intuitive Judgments. A. Gloeckner, Does Intuition Beat Fast and Frugal Heuristics? A Systematic Empirical Analysis.