Freud and the Imaginative World
Routledge – 1985 – 233 pages
The current resurgence of interest in the scientific origins of psychoanalysis has overshadowed the artistic and literary models to which Freud had recourse time and again in the development and presentation of his theories. It is this neglected aesthetic wellspring of psychoanalysis to which Harry Trosman calls attention in Freud and the Imaginative World.
Trosman enriches our understanding of psychoanalysis by demonstrating how Freud's cultural and humanistic commitments guided his pursuit of a science of mind. Toward this end, he undertakes a number of challenging tasks: to situate Freud in the formative culture of his time, to adumbrate the human concerns that infromed his work in the natural sciences, and to delineate the multiple "modes of influence" that fostered his creativity. The second part of the book moves from the cultural sources of Freud's creativity to the psychoanalytic contribution to our understanding of art and literature. Here, Trosman focuses on the consumer of art and literature, tracing psychoanalytic perspectives on aesthetic responsiveness from Freud to the present. Trosman's critical review of the da Vinci and Hamlet literature illustrates the limitations as well as the explanatory potential of the two principal genres of applied psychoanalytic work, and leads naturally to the reflective estimation of psychoanalysis and creativity that concludes the work.
Throughout, Trosman is a well-informed and engaging guide, both to the imaginative Freud and to the abundant literature on psychoanalysis and the arts. He documents Freud's continuing indebtedness to the literary models that nourished his theorizing and gave shape to his narrative clinical expositions, even as he takes pains to show how psychoanalysis has, in many ways, outgrown Freud's own reductive explanations of aesthetic phenomena. A skillfully crafted overview, Freud and the Imaginative World is an exemplary introduction to a crucial aspect of the Freudian legacy.
"Trosman offers new insights into Freud's creativity and its relation to his cultural and familial roots. His book integrates a scholarly review of psychoanalytic history, a sophisticated understanding of modern psychoanalysis, and a sensitive and respectful recognition of the unique characteristics of art and the humanities into a major new synthesis."
- Robert Michels, M.D.
"This integrative survey will be useful both to experienced workers in applied analysis and the beginning student. It is a fine presentation of many central issues in the field and is highly recommended."
- Robert Galatzer-Levy, M.D., The Psychohistory Review
I. The Claims of Humanism - Influence and Identity
- Freud and the Formative Culture
- Natural Sciences and Human Concerns
- Modes of Influence on Freud's Creativity
- Artistic and Neurotic Fantasy
- A Claim Avowed: Freud's Jewish Identity
II. Psychoanalysis and the Arts
- Freud's Style and the Matter of Style
- The Psychoanalysis of Aesthetic Response
- Comparative Views of Leonardo da Vinci and Psychoanalytic Biography
- Psychoanalysis and Literary Criticism: Hamlet as Prototype
- Psychoanalytic Views of Creativity
Harry Trosman, M.D., is Professor of Psychiatry at the University of Chicago, and a faculty member and Training and Supervising Analyst at the Chicago Institute for Psychoanalysis.