Landmark Essays on Rhetorical Invention in Writing
Edited by Richard E. Young, Yameng Liu
Routledge – 1995 – 272 pages
Series: Landmark Essays Series
In the process of assembling this collection, the editors quickly realized that no group of a dozen and a half articles can adequately represent the developments in modern rhetorical invention, even when the choices are restricted to articles on invention in writing. The articles selected for inclusion are probably best seen as synecdochic -- as representatives, albeit particularly notable ones, for whole categories of efforts to address particular questions associated with invention in writing. Each marks in the development of modern invention, if not the first major expression of the position, at least an especially significant moment in an on-going conceptual process. One useful way of thinking about these papers and their relationships is to see them as representing basic issues that run like motifs through the recent history of rhetorical invention, in particular invention in writing.
This collection presents a heteroglossia of perspectives on, models of, and insights into invention in writing. As such, the possible relationships among the articles that can be considered with profit are numerous and varied. The landmarks in this collection are not merely fossils nor is the inquiry into invention in writing a kind of antiquarian exercise. Each of the articles has useful things to say, stimulating discussions that are ongoing today. All combine to challenge scholars to continue what they began -- a copious, diverse, and fruitful effort to reinvent inventio.
Contents: R.E. Young, Y. Liu, Introduction (1994). K. Burke, The Five Master Terms (1943). M. Bilsky, M Hazlett, R.E. Streeter, R.M. Weaver, Looking for an Argument (1953). W.C. Booth, The Rhetorical Stance (1963). K.L. Pike, Beyond the Sentence (1964). R.E. Hughes, The Contemporaneity of Classical Rhetoric (1965). D.G. Rohman, Pre-Writing: The Stage of Discovery in the Writing Process (1965). C. Perelman, Rhetoric and Philosophy (1968). S. Consigny, Rhetoric and Its Situations (1974). J.E. Miller, Jr., Everyman with a Blue Guitar: Imagination, Creativity, Language (1974). S.M. Halloran, On the End of Rhetoric, Classical and Modern (1975). J. Emig, Writing as a Mode of Learning (1977). J.W. Corder, Varieties of Ethical Argument, With Some Account of the Significance of Ethos in the Teaching of Composition (1978). W.J. Ong, Literacy and Orality in Our Times (1978). J. Britton, Shaping at the Point of Utterance (1980). J.R. Hayes, L.S. Flower, Identifying the Organization of Writing Processes (1980). D.B. Park, The Meanings of "Audience" (1982). R.E. Young, Concepts of Art and the Teaching of Writing (1982). J.T. Gage, An Adequate Epistemology for Composition: Classical and Modern Perspectives (1984). J.L.K. Kairos, A Neglected Concept in Classical Rhetoric (1986).